Honey Bee Decline Due to ‘Complex’ Multiple Factors

bee, flower
Foraging honeybee (Photo by SimonaDC)


WASHINGTON, DC, May 2, 2013 (ENS) – Multiple factors are responsible for the steep decline in honey bees across the United States, including parasites and disease, genetics, poor nutrition and pesticide exposure, federal government officials reported today, releasing a new scientific consensus on honey bee health.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency officials said the report summarizes the conclusions of the National Stakeholders Conference on Honey Bee Health last October.

bee, flower
Healthy foraging honeybee (Photo by SimonaDC)

Led by federal researchers and managers, the meeting included: beekeepers, scientists, advocacy groups, beekeeping supply manufacturers, commodity groups, pesticide producers, academics, and state and federal government representatives from the United States, Canada, and Europe. It was convened to survey the current state of knowledge about the primary factors that scientists believe have the greatest impact on managed bee health now that Colony Collapse Disorder has persisted since 2006.

“Overall losses continue to be high and pose a serious threat to meeting the pollination service demands for several commercial crops,” states the meeting’s outcome report.

“The decline in honey bee health is a complex problem caused by a combination of stressors, and at EPA we are committed to continuing our work with USDA, researchers, beekeepers, growers and the public to address this challenge,” said Acting EPA Administrator Bob Perciasepe.

Federal government agencies are working with beekeepers, growers, pesticide and seed companies, said Perciasepe, “advancing new equipment and best management practices to avoid pesticide exposure to bees when they are foraging and refining ways to reduce the pesticide dust when planting.”

“Acute and sublethal effects of pesticides on honey bees have been increasingly documented, and are a primary concern,” the report states.

Perciasepe said that EPA has new data requirements and new techniques and analysis for assessing sublethal effects on bees and colony health.

“The report we’ve released today is the product of unprecedented collaboration, and our work in concert must continue,” Perciasepe said. “As the report makes clear, we’ve made significant progress, but there is still much work to be done to protect the honey bee population.”

“There is an important link between the health of American agriculture and the health of our honeybees for our country’s long term agricultural productivity,” said Agriculture Deputy Secretary Kathleen Merrigan. “The forces impacting honeybee health are complex and USDA, our research partners, and key stakeholders will be engaged in addressing this challenge.”

bee, mite
Honey bee with a Varroa mite on its back. The mites cause death and disease in bee colonies. (Photo by Scott Bauer courtesy USDA)

An estimated one-third of all food and beverages consumed in the United States are made possible by pollination, mainly by honey bees.

Across the country, pollination contributes to crop production worth $20-30 billion in agricultural production annually, but a decline in managed bee colonies puts great pressure on farmers and orchardists who rely on commercial pollination services.

Zac Browning, a fourth generation commercial beekeeper from Jamestown, North Dakota, produces honey and provides crop pollination services in North Dakota, Idaho, Washington, and California. As a past president and current legislative committee member of the American Beekeeping Federation, he knows the condition of bees across the country.

“We’re on the brink,” of failing to supply enough bees to meet the demand for pollinators, he told reporters on a conference call today introducing the report.

“The report makes it clear that bee decline is complicated, but it is not a mystery,” said Browning. “The report does a good job in breaking down the multi- stressors. Solutions will be multifacted too.”

“In my own operation,” said Browning, “my bee losses are double what they were in 2012. The symptoms we saw were not consistent with Colony Collapse Disorder. Our losses were from multiple factors: drought-stressed bees in the fall, some were the result of pesticide exposure, some were considered natural due to queen failure. We also had hives succumbing to dearth of food due to drought and combination of those factors interacting. There’s not enough habitat and what is left on the periphery is not enough to support bees.”

While the European Union last week placed restrictions on three neonicotinoid insecticides harmful to bees after a European Food Safety Authority report identified “high acute risks” for bees in dust and pollen contaminated with these pesticides, Obama Administration officials are not considering pesticide restrictions.

pesticide sign
Pesticide warning sign in California’s Central Valley (Photo by Denise Vastola)

Jim Jones, acting assistant administrator, EPA Office of Chemical Safety and Pollution Prevention, said, “The Europeans have not banned the three pesticides yet, they’re involved in a processes. We let science drive the outcome of our decisions. It’s important to get the science correct. There are nontrival costs to society if we get this wrong. Pesticide products provide benefits to farmers, and to consumers, providing affordable food in the United States. We want to make sure we make accurate and meaningful moves.”

The report finds the most pressing pesticide research questions relate to “determining actual pesticide exposures and effects of pesticides to bees in the field and the potential for impacts on bee health and productivity of whole honey bee colonies.”

The USDA is working along other lines to improve bee survival. They are addressing the decline in availability of open foraging areas over the last few years. The report says land use changes are to blame, “driven, in part, by economic and agricultural developments such as increased planting of row crops, such as corn, as commodity prices have risen, and in sites that formerly were undisturbed.”

Dr. Sonny Ramaswamy, director of the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture told reporters on the call, “At the USDA, we are working to improve pollinator-friendly habitats on federal land.”

“We are conducting a national survey to identify honeybee pests that will guide our work with farmers and ranchers to incorporate honeybee habitat enhancements on their lands,” Ramaswamy said.

Modern farming practices are making things difficult for pollinators, the report shows, especially when large and increasing swathes of farmland are being planted to corn, a crop that Browning says is of no benefit to honeybees.

“If we had better forage for pollinators we’d go a long ways in inproving pollinator health,” said Dr. Jeffery Pettis, bee research leader with the USDA Agricultural Research Service. “We’re looking at federal lands that might be made available for bees.”

The Report on the National Stakeholders Conference on Honey Bee Health states:

•    The parasitic Varroa mite is recognized as the major factor underlying colony loss in the United States and other countries. There is widespread resistance to the chemicals beekeepers use to control mites within the hive. New virus species have been found in the United States, several associated with Colony Collapse Disorder.

•    U.S. honeybee colonies need increased genetic diversity. Genetic variation improves bees’ ability to keep body temperature steady even if the surrounding environment is different, as well as disease resistance and worker productivity.

•    Honey bee breeding should emphasize traits such as hygienic behavior that confer improved resistance to Varroa mites and diseases such as American foulbrood.

•    Nutrition has a major impact on individual bee and colony longevity. A nutrition-poor diet can make bees more susceptible to harm from disease and parasites. Bees need better forage and a variety of plants to support colony health.

•    Federal and state partners should consider actions affecting land management to maximize available nutritional forage to promote and enhance good bee health and to protect bees by keeping them away from pesticide-treated fields.

•    Best Management Practices associated with bees and pesticide use, exist, but are not widely or systematically followed by members of the crop-producing industry. There is a need for informed and coordinated communication between growers and beekeepers and effective collaboration between stakeholders on practices to protect bees from pesticides.

•    Beekeepers emphasized the need for accurate and timely bee kill incident reporting, monitoring, and enforcement.

Those involved in developing the report include: USDA’s Office of Pest Management Policy, National Institute of Food and Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, National Resource Conservation Service as well as the EPA and Pennsylvania State University.

Please click here to view the report, which will inform the work of the USDA’s Colony Collapse Steering Committee.

Copyright Environment News Service (ENS) 2013. All rights reserved.

Continue Reading