Gas Hub Out of Whale Nursery on Australia’s Kimberley Coast

humpback whales
Humpback whale with calf off James Price Point, Western Australia (Photo courtesy Sea Shepherd)


MELBOURNE, Australia, April 12, 2013 (ENS) – Woodside Petroleum has shelved plans for a $4.5 billion liquid natural gas processing plant at James Price Point. The site on Western Australia’s pristine Kimberley coast is also the site of the world’s largest humpback whale nursery.

In the winter birthing season, more than 10,000 humpbacks gather there and hundreds of calves are born. Blue whales, the world’s largest animals, pass through these waters to calve further north.

humpback whales
Humpback whale with calf off James Price Point, Western Australia (Photo courtesy Sea Shepherd Australia)

Woodside has already cleared many of the permitting hurdles required to build the Browse LNG processing plant at James Price Point, but today the company said an internal review of the project found it would not deliver the financial returns the company needs to proceed.

“At this point we believe that it is not commercial to proceed with the James Price Point project,” said Woodside CEO and Managing Director Peter Coleman, announcing the decision.

Coleman said the company would consider other alternatives such as a floating terminal, but for now the project is on hold. Shareholders applauded the decision with a surge in the company’s share price.

Woodside and the West Australian Government had planned to develop one of the world’s biggest industrial complexes, drilling and dredging up to six kilometers out to sea, with a large ships jetty several kilometers long built through the middle of the whale nursery.

Last July, the nonprofit conservation organization Sea Shepherd, known for its success in driving Japanese whalers out of Australian waters, received an invitation from the Goolarabooloo Aboriginal people to help them halt construction of the Woodside LNG facility.

“Our Sea Country here is the home of the Humpback whale. We have seen the work you have done to protect the whales in the Southern Ocean. We would appreciate any support you can give us to protect the Humpback in our Sea Country from the proposal to build an industrial port at James Price Point for LNG export,” wrote Goolarabooloo Senior Law Bosses, Joseph Roe, Phillip Roe and Richard Hunter.

“Sea Shepherd accepts the invitation in the spirit of eternal friendship with a promise to stand in unity with the Goolarabooloo to defend the beauty and sacredness of this wondrous environment,” said the group’s founder Captain Paul Watson.

“In honoring the Goolarabooloo, we are naming this campaign operation Kimberley Miinimbi, the Goolarabooloo name for humpback whale,” Watson said.

The ocean’s uncontaminated state at the proposed site has resulted in a rare abundance of green, flat back, loggerhead, and hawksbill turtles, numerous species of whales and dolphins, migratory birds, fish including manta rays and sharks, dugongs, plankton, sea-grass and coral.

Paul Vogel
Dr. Paul Vogel chairs the Western Australia Environmental Protection Authority (Photo courtesy WAEPA)

Still, in July 2012, the LNG gas hub had been given a conditional go-ahead by Western Australia’s Environmental Protection Authority, even though four of the five board members stood aside due to conflicts of interest.

EPA Chairman Dr. Paul Vogel, the one board member who authorized the project, admitted that turbidity from dredging, oil spills, industrial discharges, noise, light and vessel strikes could adversely affect whales, dolphins, turtles, dugong and fish.

“It has taken over three decades for the Western Australian humpback population to bounce back from the brink of extinction due to whaling,” Sea Shepherd Australia then said to its supporters. “If you stand by us in defending the humpbacks in their Antarctic summer feeding grounds, then please stand by us in defense of their birthing grounds.”

LNG site
The LNG factory site as of August 2012 (Photo courtesy Sea Shepherd)

With the support of the Australian Greens and under the leadership of former Greens Senator Bob Brown, who now heads Sea Shepherd Australia, the group began to publicize the issue, drawing more than 700 people to a demonstration in Sydney against the gas hub and targeting local and federal officials, such as Environment Minister Tony Burke, with emails.

Western Australia Premier Colin Barnett called Woodside’s decision to withdraw from the project “a tragedy and a missed opportunity.”

Premier Barnett told “The West Australian” newspaper that the state would miss out on the opportunity “for literally thousands of people to work on the construction and hundreds to work on the ongoing operation and for gas to be available in our economy.”

But Sea Shepherd Australia said, “Constructing the gas factories and port would mean noise pollution, destruction of habitat and also boat strikes to whales. If the gas factories went ahead it would open the door to the industrialization of other parts of the region and could lead to coal and uranium shipments out of the Kimberley wilds.”

Premier Barnett expressed concern that Woodside’s withdrawal would “break the hearts of Aboriginal people” who had been poised to receive a $1.5 billion benefits package in compensation for native title to James Price Point.

Brown said the native people should still get the payment, although he differed from Barnett in specifying the amount. “It is now essential that the 1.3 billion dollar payment to the traditional owners from exploiting the Browse basin gas be guaranteed even though the processing is likely to occur 400 kilometers off the coast,” said Brown.

Sea Shepherd Australia Director Jeff Hansen was amazed and delighted by the whales he saw when he sailed the organization’s flagship, the Steve Irwin, to the area last August.

humpback whale
Humpback whale and the Steve Irwin just off
James Price Point, August 2012 (Photo courtesy Sea Shepherd)

“On my first day I witnessed mothers and calves nursing less than one kilometer off the former proposed site. In a place with stunning turquoise water, vibrant red cliffs, a rich and ancient culture going back tens of thousands of years and dinosaur footprints dating back over 230 million years, I could not comprehend what Woodside and the state government were contemplating,” said Hansen.

“My feeling was that I would challenge anyone to come to the Kimberley and not be affected immensely by its raw beauty and not want to stand alongside the Goolarabooloo in defense of one of the last wilderness areas left on the planet,” said Hansen. “Now, I encourage anyone to go and see the Kimberley for yourself, to meet the wonderful folk of Broome, the Goolarabooloo and one of Earth’s precious gifts, that is, the Kimberley.”

Despite the increased pressure from the Sea Shepherd and other conservation groups, Woodside’s Coleman said it was not environmental considerations that determined the company’s decision.

“The decision is a commercial one,” Coleman said today. While we have seen an increase in both the environmental and administrative compliance requirements and procedures, Woodside very highest standards in those areas. We have diligently worked through those requirements while we’ve assessed the James Price Point option.”

Hansen said the outcome shows the value of perseverance. “On announcing operation Kimberley Miinimbi, many people believed that there was no hope in stopping this project. That it was a David and Goliath struggle and we could not win this. This victory shows that no matter what the odds, no matter what the risks, no matter how well equipped, funded and government backed your opponents are, you must never give in, must never surrender, you must fight for what is right, because the one thing that is worth fighting for on our beautiful planet, is life.”

Now Sea Shepherd and the traditional owners of the Kimberley region are calling for assessment of the site for protection under UNESCO’s World Heritage treaty.

Copyright Environment News Service (ENS) 2013. All rights reserved.

Continue Reading